Free tool
Free-shipping threshold optimizer
What happens to average order value and contribution margin if you set a free-shipping threshold at each of several points around your current AOV. Directional, honest, and it names its own limits.
| Threshold | Order value | Contribution / order | vs no threshold |
|---|---|---|---|
| $50.00 | $57.17 | $29.49 | -$3.91 |
| $60.00 | $58.26 | $30.69 | -$2.71 |
| $65.00 | $59.00 | $31.41 | -$1.99 |
| $70.00 | $59.87 | $32.20 | -$1.20 |
| $80.00 | $62.00 | $34.02 | +$0.62 |
| $85.00 Best | $63.26 | $35.05 | +$1.65 |
Directional, not prescriptive. Category, price sensitivity and how you present the threshold all move the real numbers. Chapter 6, the checkout chapter, walks through the trade in more depth.
Stay sharp on ecommerce CRO
3 short examples, 2 CRO tips, 1 teardown. Every Tuesday.
What this calculator does
It prices free shipping as what it is: a discount you hand to every qualifying order, paid for by the buyers who add something to reach the bar. Give it your average order value, your shipping cost per order, and your product margin, and it models six candidate thresholds around your AOV and reports contribution per order at each.
It is for stores deciding whether to introduce a threshold, and for stores that already have one set at a number nobody can remember choosing. If shipping is a meaningful cost line for you, this is a fifteen-second sanity check before a change that touches every order you take.
The maths, in the open
One simplifying assumption does the heavy lifting: the further the threshold sits above your AOV, the larger the share of orders that fall below it. The rest is arithmetic.
threshold = AOV × (1 + step), rounded to the nearest $5
share below = 0.5 + (threshold ÷ AOV − 1) × 0.6, clamped to 0–0.9
topped off = share below × top-off rate
order value = topped off × threshold + (share below − topped off) × AOV + share above ×
AOV
contribution = order value × margin − (topped off + share above) × ship cost
baseline = AOV × margin − (1 − share who previously paid) × ship cost
The six steps are −15%, 0, +10%, +20%, +35% and +50% against your AOV. Buyers who top off are modelled as spending exactly the threshold, not a cent more. The baseline is the world before the threshold, where the share you name covered their own delivery and you absorbed the rest, so every row is measured against "no threshold at all" rather than against your current one.
A worked example
The defaults: a $58 average order value, $7 to ship an order, 60% product margin, and one in four below-threshold buyers topping off to qualify, and 80% of buyers previously paying their own shipping. Baseline contribution is $33.40 per order.
| Threshold | Order value | Contribution | vs no threshold |
|---|---|---|---|
| $50.00 | $57.17 | $29.49 | −$3.91 |
| $60.00 | $58.26 | $30.69 | −$2.71 |
| $65.00 | $59.00 | $31.41 | −$1.99 |
| $70.00 | $59.87 | $32.20 | −$1.20 |
| $80.00 | $62.00 | $34.02 | +$0.62 |
| $85.00 | $63.26 | $35.05 | +$1.65 |
Four of the six lose money. Order value climbs as the threshold rises (that is the part everyone screenshots) and contribution still trails the baseline for the first four rows, because a $7 giveaway on a large share of orders costs more than a few topped-off baskets return. Only thresholds around 38% and 47% above AOV clear the cost, and the better of them clears it by $1.65 an order. Note the first row too: at a $50 threshold the modelled order value lands below your current AOV, because top-off buyers are assumed to stop dead on the number.
How to read the result
Read the contribution column, not the order value column. AOV going up is not the same as making money. A threshold that lifts AOV 9% and cuts contribution per order is a loss dressed as a win, and it is the single most common way this decision gets made badly.
A thin margin between rows means it does not matter much. If the best row beats the baseline by cents, the threshold is not your problem. Go and look at the product page instead.
Treat the winning row as a hypothesis. It is the number to try, watched against AOV and conversion rate together for a full month, not a setting to ship and forget.
What it will not do
Model your actual order distribution. The share-below curve is a straight line through your AOV, not your real basket histogram. Stores with tightly clustered orders, or two distinct price tiers, behave nothing like it.
Model abandonment. Push the threshold far enough above AOV and buyers stop topping off and start leaving. Nothing in the formula bends downward, so the highest threshold will often look best when it would not be.
Tell you how many customers used to pay. The "share who previously paid shipping" input sets the baseline you are compared against: at 80%, four in five orders covered their own delivery before the threshold existed, so going free costs you more. You have to supply that number from your own reporting, and most stores guess it.
Handle subscriptions, heavy goods or zoned rates. One flat shipping cost per order is the assumption. If your cost varies by weight, region or carrier, model it yourself with your own numbers.
What this tool cannot tell you
Whether your customers behave like the average customer. Categories with tight AOV clusters, subscription models, and any store where shipping is a real cost driver need their own numbers, not a heuristic.
Use the "Best" row as a starting hypothesis. Run it as a real change, watch AOV and conversion together for a full month, and be honest about which one moved.
The reasoning behind the trade is in Chapter 6 of the free course. To size the test that confirms it, use the significance calculator.
All three calculators, live on one page → Significance, programme ROI and the free-shipping threshold, with what to do about each.
What founders ask before they book.
Should the threshold sit above or below AOV?
Above, usually. A threshold below AOV is picked up automatically by nearly everyone and gains you nothing. Above AOV creates a real decision (pay shipping, or add another item to skip it), which is where the AOV lift comes from.
How much above AOV should it sit?
Typically 20–35% above, depending on how tightly clustered orders are around AOV. Too far above and no one crosses it; too close and it functions as no threshold at all. The table shows several options rather than one answer because the right point is store-specific.
Does this account for the shipping fees I used to collect?
Yes. The model charges you the shipping cost on every order that now qualifies for free delivery, and the "share who previously paid shipping" input sets what you are compared against. The higher it is, the more delivery revenue you are giving up, and the harder the threshold has to work. Set it to zero and the comparison assumes you were already absorbing shipping on every order.
Is a bigger free-shipping threshold always better for AOV?
No. Push the threshold too high and buyers who would have added a topping-off item at $60 instead abandon at $95. The model does not capture that non-linearity, so treat the "Best" row as a directional shortlist for testing, not an answer.
Why does the default example say almost every threshold loses money?
Because free shipping is a discount and the model prices it as one. On a $58 AOV with a $7 ship cost and 60% margin, only the highest threshold clears the cost of giving delivery away. That is the trade the tool exists to make visible.
Want the threshold set on your store instead of modelled?
We will pull your real AOV distribution, model it against your margins, and hand you the number. Free 20-minute call.
Got it. Now pick a time.
Open the calendar →Twenty minutes on your store and your numbers. If we cannot help we will say so.
- 437+ stores built
- 2,000+ tests shipped
- No call needed to start